Best of the tests
User's picks
Columnists' picks
Reviewers' advice
More product reviews
 
Search /
Docfinder:
Advanced search  |  Help  |  Site map
RESEARCH CENTERS
SITE RESOURCES
Click for Layer 8! No, really, click NOW!
Networking for Small Business
TODAY'S NEWS
FCC chairman gives support for use of 'white spaces'
Cyber security threats grow in sophistication, subtlety and power
Ex-Google, Yahoo employees behind Hadoop startup
Ex-Enron Broadband exec pleads guilty to wire fraud
Quest's post-acquisition road map a killer for NetPro
Cisco rolls out TelePresence rental service
Willing to pay a 'Mac tax'?
Microsoft reveals critical holes in Active Directory, mainframe gateway
Intel reports record Q3 revenue
Federal employees lack tools for mobile work, study finds
Apple's new MacBooks carved from blocks of aluminum
How bad is U.S. broadband deployment?
Cisco iPrize goes to energy-efficient power grid
Cisco launches first-ever authorized CCIE training program
Novell buying Managed Objects for BSM


Corporate NetworksSignature Series
    
What's a Preference Rating?
This specialized rating gives us a way of figuring out how a product's market share affects its rank in our Best Products survey.


  | Back to Best Products: User Picks |

The Preference Rating, which adjusts for the statistical advantage of high market share, supplements the straight percentage results we garner in our annual Best Products survey.

To determine both results, we e-mailed a group of Network World readers asking them to participate in this private Web survey. We received 504 completed entries, with two-thirds from large companies (1,000 or more employees). Respondents came from 16 industries, with manufacturing, education, government, finance and retail/wholesale trade topping the list.

We asked participants to tell us which products they used, choosing from a drop-down list, and then which of these products they deemed best. King, Brown & Partners, a survey firm in Sausalito, Calif., calculated the percentage of best votes and the Preference Rating. 

A product with a high market share (percentage of "use" votes) has a better chance of earning a higher number of "best" votes than a product with fewer users. A product that earns a high number of best votes compared with its number of users will have a high Preference Rating. The converse is also true. 

For example, in the desktop management software category, 49% of participants said they used Microsoft's Systems Management Server 2.0. Yet only 31% voted it best. SMS therefore had a Preference Rating of 0.63. In contrast, 34% use Novell's ZENworks, yet 36% voted it best, landing it a 1.06 Preference Rating.

A 1.0 score is the baseline. A score above 1.0 indicates voters thought the product better than its competitors. Those that scored below 1.0 illustrate the reverse (see Highest and Lowest charts).

- Julie Bort and Brenda Stull, research director, King, Brown & Partners


Desktop management software

Magic Solutions’ (Network Associates) Zero Administration Client Suite
1.50
Network performance management software

Lucent’s VitalNet
1.25
Load-balancing switches

Foundry Networks’ ServerIron
1.25
Enterprise e-commerce platforms

Blue Martini’s Commerce
1.33
Enterprise collocation service

IBM Global Services’ Facilities Hosting services
1.25
VPN appliances

Nokia’s Firewall/VPN Appliance;
Symantec’s VelociRaptor; NetScreen’s NetScreen-100; RedCreek’s Ravlin
1.00
Network-attached storage

IBM’s TotalStorage NAS 200 and 300 series
1.36
Public-key infrastructure software

Baltimore Technologies’ UniCERT;
Certicom’s Trustpoint Certificate Authority
1.50
Enterprise voice-over-IP gateways

Cisco’s AS5x00 universal access servers
1.02
Commercial Linux distributions

No Linux distribution earned a score of 1.0 or above
 
Desktop management software

Marimba’s Castanet
0.33
Network performance management software

Network Associates’ Sniffer Portable LAN
0.69
Load-balancing switches

Lucent’s imminet WebDirector
0.33
Enterprise e-commerce platforms

BroadVision’s BroadVision One-To-One Enterprise 6.0
0.25
Enterprise collocation service

Globix’s Co-location XO Communications’ Server Collocation
0.50
VPN appliances

WatchGuard’s Firebox
0.71
Network-attached storage

Procom Technology’s NetForce 3100 HA
0.50
Public-key infrastructure software

iPlanet’s Certificate Management System
0.43
Enterprise voice-over-IP gateways

Ericsson’s WebSwitch
0.33
Commercial Linux distributions

Caldera Systems’ OpenLinux series;
Mandrakesoft’s Linux-Mandrake 8.0
0.39

Related Links

NWFusion offers more than 40 FREE technology-specific email newsletters in key network technology areas such as NSM, VPNs, Convergence, Security and more.
Click here to sign up!
New Event - WANs: Optimizing Your Network Now.
Hear from the experts about the innovations that are already starting to shake up the WAN world. Free Network World Technology Tour and Expo in Dallas, San Francisco, Washington DC, and New York.
Attend FREE
Your FREE Network World subscription will also include breaking news and information on wireless, storage, infrastructure, carriers and SPs, enterprise applications, videoconferencing, plus product reviews, technology insiders, management surveys and technology updates - GET IT NOW.
* HOME    * RESEARCH CENTERS     * NEWS     * EVENTS

Contact us | Terms of Service/Privacy | How to Advertise
Reprints and links | Partnerships | Subscribe to NW
About Network World, Inc.

Copyright, 1994-2006 Network World, Inc. All rights reserved.